Glossary
Failure to deliver (FTD)
A trade that does not settle on time because the seller has not delivered the shares; tracked by regulators and limited by Regulation SHO.
A failure to deliver (FTD) happens when the seller in a trade does not hand over the securities by the settlement date. US stock trades have settled one business day after the trade (T+1) since May 28, 2024.
Why fails happen
- Operational delays: paperwork for shares held in certificate form, errors, transfers between custodians.
- Short sales without borrowed shares. A short seller must deliver borrowed shares. If the borrow falls through, or was never arranged, the trade fails. See naked short selling.
- Market making. A market maker may sell before it has located shares, which the rules allow for genuine market making.
A fail does not cancel the trade. The buyer's account shows the position, and the clearinghouse carries the obligation until delivery.
What the rules require
The SEC's Regulation SHO, in force since 2005, sets the limits.
- Close-out. A broker with a fail from a short sale must buy or borrow shares by the start of trading on the next settlement day. Fails from sales of shares the seller owns, and from market making, get two more days.
- Penalty. Until it closes out, the broker cannot sell that stock short without borrowing the shares in advance.
- Threshold list. A stock goes on an exchange's daily threshold list when fails reach at least 10,000 shares and 0.5% of shares outstanding for five straight settlement days.
The data
The SEC publishes total fails for each stock twice a month.
Limits
Large fail counts are often read as proof of manipulation. They can equally reflect ordinary delays, especially in ETFs.
