Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Glossary

Mental accounting

Treating money differently depending on where it came from or what it is labeled for, even though every dollar can be spent the same way.

On this page
  1. Common patterns in investing
  2. When it helps
  3. The cost
  4. Limits
  5. Related terms

Mental accounting is the habit of sorting money into separate mental categories and treating each by its own rules. Economist Richard Thaler described it in a 1985 paper. In standard economics money is fungible: a dollar is a dollar, whatever its source. In practice people treat a tax refund, a salary, a bonus and a gambling win quite differently.

Common patterns in investing

  • House money. Gains already made feel like someone else's money and are risked more freely. A trader up 30% this year may take bets they would never take with their savings.
  • Dividends as income. Many investors spend dividends but would never sell shares, though selling a small amount of stock would have the same effect on their wealth. See dividend.
  • One position at a time. Each holding is judged on its own gain or loss, which feeds the disposition effect, instead of looking at the portfolio as a whole.
  • Separate pots. Holding expensive credit card debt while keeping savings in a low-interest account labeled "emergency".

When it helps

Not all mental accounting is costly. Earmarking money for a goal, such as a retirement account that is not touched for other purposes, helps many people save. Bucket approaches to retirement spending use the same idea deliberately.

The cost

Decisions that look sensible account by account can add up to a portfolio that is riskier, or less efficient, than intended. Looking at all accounts together, as one allocation, is the usual check.

Limits

The line between a useful rule of thumb and an expensive habit depends on the person and the amounts involved.