Glossary
Disposition effect
The tendency of investors to sell holdings that have gained and keep holdings that have lost, which is the reverse of what the tax code rewards.
On this page
The disposition effect is the pattern of selling winners quickly and holding losers. Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman named it in 1985. They explained it by loss aversion and by the wish to avoid the regret of admitting a mistake.
The evidence
The best-known study is by Terrance Odean, published in 1998. He examined about 10,000 accounts at a US discount broker from 1987 to 1993 and found that investors realized their gains at roughly one and a half times the rate at which they realized their losses. Over the following year, the winners they sold went on to beat the losers they kept by about 3.4 percentage points on average.
Why it costs money
- Taxes. In a taxable US account, realizing a gain creates a tax bill and realizing a loss can reduce one. The disposition effect does the opposite of tax-loss harvesting.
- Momentum. Stocks that have risen over recent months have tended, on average, to keep outperforming for a while.
- The wrong question. The price you paid has no bearing on a stock's future. See anchoring.
Limits
The effect is an average across many investors. Selling a winner can be right when the price has run ahead of the business, and keeping a loser can be right when the reason for owning it still holds.
