Glossary
Implementation shortfall
The gap between the return of a trade on paper at the decision price and the return actually achieved, after impact, costs and any part of the order never filled.
Implementation shortfall is the difference between what a trading decision would have earned on paper, at the price when the decision was made, and what the real trades earned. André Perold of Harvard Business School named it in a 1988 paper. It captures every cost of acting on an idea: the spread, the price moving against the order while it fills, commissions, and the cost of shares never bought.
The starting price is often called the arrival price or decision price. Unlike a VWAP benchmark, it cannot be met simply by trading along with the day's volume.
The trade-off it exposes
Trading fast raises market impact; trading slowly risks the price drifting away and leaves part of the order unfilled. Implementation-shortfall algorithms try to balance the two, usually trading harder early. Brokers report execution quality against such benchmarks as part of best execution reviews, and the per-share version is slippage.
Related terms
Sources and further reading
- André F. Perold, “The Implementation Shortfall: Paper Versus Reality,” Journal of Portfolio Management 14(3), Spring 1988
