Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Glossary

Guardrails withdrawal strategy

A retirement spending rule that starts at a fixed withdrawal, raises it with inflation, and cuts or raises it 10% when the withdrawal rate drifts too far.

On this page
  1. The Guyton-Klinger rules
  2. The catch
  3. Related terms

A guardrails strategy is a rule for retirement withdrawals that starts at a fixed amount, raises it with inflation like the 4% rule, and changes it in steps when markets push the plan too far off course. The guardrails are two thresholds on the current withdrawal rate: this year's withdrawal divided by the current balance.

It trades a pay cut in bad years for a higher starting income. The best-known version was published by Jonathan Guyton and William Klinger in 2006.

The Guyton-Klinger rules

  • Capital preservation. If the current rate rises more than 20% above the starting rate, cut this year's withdrawal by 10%. With a 5% start, the trigger is a rate above 6%. It stops applying 15 years before the end of the plan.
  • Prosperity. If the current rate falls more than 20% below the start, below 4% for a 5% start, raise the withdrawal by 10%.
  • No raise after a loss. Skip the inflation raise after a year with a negative return when the rate is above its start, and never make it up.

In their simulations, with at least 65% in stocks, the rules supported starting rates of 5.2% to 5.6% over 40 years.

The catch

Guardrails defend against sequence of returns risk by moving it onto income. From January 2007, a 5% plan cut spending in 2009, skipped three raises and never got one.

Sources and further reading

  1. Jonathan T. Guyton and William J. Klinger, “Decision Rules and Maximum Initial Withdrawal Rates,” Journal of Financial Planning (March 2006)