Glossary
Framing effect
The tendency to choose differently when the same facts are presented another way, as a gain or a loss, in points or percent, or over a short or long period.
The framing effect is the finding that people make different choices from the same facts when those facts are described differently. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed it in 1981: 72% of people picked a sure option when outcomes were worded as lives saved, and 78% picked a gamble when the same outcomes were worded as lives lost. A gain frame makes people cautious; a loss frame makes them take risks, as prospect theory predicts.
Frames investors meet
- Points or percent. Index moves in points grow with the index level, so they look bigger every decade.
- The period shown. In one experiment, savers shown one-year stock returns put a median 40% in stocks. Shown the same history as 30-year returns, they put 90%.
- One holding or the whole portfolio. Judging each position alone, called narrow framing, makes every small loss loom large. It feeds loss aversion and mental accounting.
A frame cannot be avoided, since every fact arrives in some form. Restating it in a second frame, percent beside points or ten years beside one day, shows whether the choice still looks the same.
Related terms
Sources and further reading
- Tversky and Kahneman — The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice, Science 211(4481), 1981
- Benartzi and Thaler — Risk aversion or myopia? Choices in repeated gambles and retirement investments, Management Science 45(3), 1999
