Glossary
Constructive sale
A US tax rule (IRC section 1259) that treats locking in a gain on a stock, by shorting it or a similar hedge, as a sale that is taxed now.
A constructive sale is a hedge the US tax code treats as if it were a sale. Under Internal Revenue Code §1259, added by the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, an investor who holds an appreciated position and enters a transaction that removes nearly all of its risk and reward must recognize the capital gain at once, even though nothing was sold.
The classic target was "shorting against the box": owning a stock and selling it short at the same time. It locked in the price while deferring the tax for years. Section 1259 ended that.
What triggers it
A constructive sale occurs when the holder of an appreciated stock, partnership interest or certain debt:
- sells short the same or substantially identical property;
- enters an offsetting swap on it;
- enters a futures or forward contract to deliver it.
The position is treated as sold at fair market value that day. Its basis rises by the gain taxed, and a new holding period starts.
The exception. The hedge is ignored if it is closed by the 30th day after the tax year ends (January 30, 2027 here) and the stock is then held for 60 days without being hedged again. A wide collar is generally not treated as a constructive sale, since Treasury has not issued regulations covering it.
