Glossary
Active share
The percentage of a fund's holdings that differs from its benchmark index, used to tell real stock picking from index hugging.
Active share measures how different a fund's portfolio is from its benchmark. A fund identical to the index has an active share of 0%. A fund with no holdings in common has 100%. Martijn Cremers and Antti Petajisto introduced the measure in a 2009 paper.
How it is used
- Spotting closet indexers. A fund that charges active fees and has low active share cannot beat its index by much, since most of it is the index. The original paper used 60% as the line below which a fund was a closet indexer.
- Judging fees. Dividing the expense ratio by active share shows the fee on the part that is truly active. A 0.9% fee on a fund with 30% active share is 3% on the active part.
Active share and tracking error
Tracking error measures how differently the fund's returns behave. Active share measures how differently it is built. A fund making many small stock bets can have high active share and modest tracking error.
Limits
High active share shows that a fund is different. It does not show that the fund is better. Later studies disputed the claim that high active share predicts higher returns. The figure also depends on the benchmark chosen, and it is naturally higher for small-company funds, whose indexes hold many names at tiny weights.
