Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Glossary

Active management

Running a fund by choosing investments in an attempt to beat a benchmark, as opposed to simply holding everything in an index.

On this page
  1. What an active manager does
  2. The arithmetic against it
  3. Where the debate remains
  4. Related terms

Active management means a fund manager decides which securities to own, and when, with the aim of doing better than a benchmark such as the S&P 500. The alternative is passive investing, where an index fund simply holds what is in the index.

What an active manager does

The manager may pick individual stocks, favor some sectors over others, hold cash when prices look high, or use a strategy such as value or momentum. The return above the benchmark, after adjusting for risk, is called alpha.

The arithmetic against it

Before costs, all investors together own the market, so the average dollar earns the market's return. Active funds charge more than index funds and trade more, so after costs the average actively managed dollar must earn less than the index.

The S&P SPIVA scorecards, which track this, have reported for years that a large majority of US large-company stock funds trail the S&P 500 over 10 and 15 years, usually more than 80%. Funds that beat the index in one period are not reliably the same ones that beat it in the next.

Where the debate remains

Active managers have had better records in some less-followed areas, such as certain bond and small-company markets, though results vary by period. Low-cost active funds also do better than expensive ones, because cost is the handicap. An active fund's fee shows in its expense ratio; how different it really is from its index shows in its tracking error.

Sources and further reading

  1. S&P Dow Jones Indices — SPIVA scorecards