Glossary
Ricardian equivalence
The theory that tax cuts paid for by borrowing do not raise spending, because people save the windfall to meet the taxes that will repay the debt.
Ricardian equivalence is the idea that it makes no difference to spending whether a government pays its way with taxes now or with borrowing that must be repaid by taxes later. If households see that a tax cut funded by a budget deficit means higher taxes ahead, they save the cut instead of spending it, and the economy is left where it was.
Robert Barro gave the modern version in "Are Government Bonds Net Wealth?" in the Journal of Political Economy in 1974. The name refers to David Ricardo, who set out the reasoning in 1820 and then doubted that people actually behave that way.
Why it rarely holds in full
The theory needs strong assumptions:
- People look far ahead and care about taxes their heirs will pay.
- They can borrow and save freely. A household short of cash spends a windfall.
- Taxes are lump sums, not taxes on income that change how much people work.
Studies of the US tax rebates of 2001 and 2008 found households spent a sizable share within months, which strict equivalence rules out. Most economists treat it as a benchmark, with the truth somewhere between it and the full Keynesian effect described under fiscal multiplier.
For investors
If equivalence held, deficits would not push up interest rates or cause crowding out, and tax cuts would not lift consumer spending or the profits of companies that sell to consumers. Bond investors who worry about large deficits are, in effect, betting that it does not hold in full.
Related terms
Sources and further reading
- Barro, R. — Are Government Bonds Net Wealth?, Journal of Political Economy 82(6), 1974
- Ricardo, D. — Essay on the Funding System (1820); Library of Economics and Liberty
