Glossary
Proxy access
A bylaw letting long-term shareholders put their own director nominees on the company ballot, usually after holding 3% for three years.
Proxy access is a company rule that lets qualifying shareholders nominate a few directors and have those nominees listed in the company's own proxy statement, next to the board's candidates. Without it, a shareholder who wants a different director must run a separate campaign with their own proxy materials, a proxy fight that can cost millions of dollars.
How it came about
- 2010. In the US, the SEC adopted Rule 14a-11, which would have given proxy access at every public company to holders of 3% for three years.
- 2011. The D.C. Circuit struck the rule down in Business Roundtable v. SEC, finding the SEC had not weighed its costs properly. The SEC did keep a change letting shareholder proposals ask for proxy access company by company.
- 2015. The New York City pension funds, which had filed proxy-access proposals at 75 companies in late 2014 asking for 3% held three years and up to 25% of the board, took them to votes. Many passed, and large companies began adopting the bylaws on their own. By the early 2020s most S&P 500 companies had one.
The common terms
The market settled on "3/3/20/20":
- own 3% of the shares,
- for three years,
- to nominate up to 20% of the board (usually at least two seats),
- with up to 20 holders allowed to combine shares to reach 3%.
In practice
Proxy access is used rarely. Its threat matters more: a board facing a credible nomination often negotiates. Since 2022 the SEC's universal proxy rule (Rule 14a-19) has made contested elections easier in a different way, by putting both sides' nominees on one card.
