Glossary
Magic formula investing
A stock-ranking method from Joel Greenblatt that buys companies scoring well on both earnings yield and return on capital.
The magic formula is a rules-based way to pick stocks that investor Joel Greenblatt set out in a 2005 book. Its aim is to buy good businesses at cheap prices by ranking companies on one measure of each.
The two measures
- Cheapness: earnings yield, defined here as EBIT divided by enterprise value. Higher means more operating profit per dollar paid for the whole business.
- Quality: return on capital, defined as EBIT divided by the sum of net working capital and net fixed assets. Higher means the business earns more on the physical capital it uses.
The steps
- Start with companies above a minimum size. Leave out banks, insurers and utilities, whose accounts do not suit the ratios.
- Rank all companies by earnings yield, and separately by return on capital.
- Add the two ranks. The lowest totals are the best.
- Buy 20 to 30 of the top-ranked stocks, spread over a year.
- Sell each after about a year and replace it from a fresh ranking.
What to keep in mind
- Published results came from a backtest ending in 2004. Independent studies of later periods have found smaller and less consistent advantages.
- It lags for years at a time. Value-based methods trailed the market for much of the 2010s. Few people keep following a formula through that.
- It uses last year's numbers. A company at a cyclical peak looks both cheap and excellent.
- Turnover creates taxes and costs, mostly short-term gains in a taxable account.
This is a description of a method, not a recommendation to use it.
