Glossary
Earnings quality
How well reported profit reflects real, repeatable cash-generating performance, as opposed to accounting estimates, one-offs or aggressive choices.
On this page
Earnings quality describes how far a company's reported earnings can be trusted to show its true, ongoing performance. High-quality earnings are backed by cash, come from the core business, and are likely to recur. Low-quality earnings depend on estimates, one-time gains or accounting choices that flatter the current period.
Common tests
- Cash conversion. Compare operating cash flow with net income over several years. Cash consistently below profit is a warning.
- The accruals ratio. The part of earnings not backed by cash, scaled by assets.
A high figure means a large part of profit consists of accruals: receivables, inventory build-ups and estimates. Richard Sloan found in 1996 that companies with high accruals tended to report lower earnings and returns in the following years.
Other signs to check
- Recurring "one-time" charges that appear every year.
- Gaps between GAAP and adjusted earnings that keep widening.
- Changes in estimates, such as longer depreciation lives or lower bad-debt reserves, that add to profit.
- Revenue recognized early or pulled forward. See channel stuffing.
- Gains from asset sales or tax benefits counted in earnings growth.
Limits
Cash and earnings differ for good reasons in growing companies, which need working capital. A single year's gap proves little. Earnings quality is an assessment, not a figure in the accounts.
