Glossary
Dutch auction
An auction in which bidders state the price and amount they want, and all winners pay the single price at which the whole offering sells.
In finance, a Dutch auction is a way to sell or buy securities at one price set by the bids themselves. Investors submit the quantity they want and the price they will accept. The seller ranks the bids and finds the clearing price, the price at which the entire amount is taken up. Everyone who bid at least that well receives the clearing price.
The name comes from Dutch flower markets, where the price starts high and drops until someone buys. The financial version keeps the idea of finding the highest price that sells everything.
Where it is used
- Treasury auctions. The US Treasury sells its bills, notes and bonds this way.
- IPOs. A few companies have used it in place of the usual process, in which underwriters set the price and choose who gets shares. The best-known case is Google in 2004.
- Share buybacks. In a "modified Dutch auction" tender offer, a company names a price range. Shareholders state the lowest price in the range at which they would sell. The company pays the lowest price that lets it buy the amount it wants.
The argument for it
An auction lets demand set the price. In a traditional IPO, a large first-day jump means the company sold its shares for less than buyers would have paid.
Limits
Auctions for IPOs remain rare. Inexperienced bidders may bid too high, banks earn less and have little reason to promote the method, and companies value the underwriters' choice of long-term shareholders.
