Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Glossary

Direct indexing

Owning an index's individual stocks in your own managed account instead of a fund, mainly to harvest tax losses stock by stock.

On this page
  1. How it works
  2. Trade-offs
  3. Related terms

Direct indexing means owning an index's stocks, or a sample of them, in your own account instead of buying a fund that holds them. An adviser, usually through software, keeps the holdings near the index's weights and trades them in a separately managed account in your name. The main reason is tax: a portfolio of hundreds of stocks almost always holds some below their purchase price, even when the index is up.

How it works

Software checks each lot and sells those far enough below cost to realize a capital loss, then buys a similar stock so the portfolio keeps its shape without breaking the wash-sale rule. In the US, net capital losses offset gains, then up to $3,000 a year of ordinary income, with the rest carried forward (IRS Topic 409). Owners can also leave out companies or industries.

Trade-offs

  • Harvesting mostly defers tax, because each replacement stock starts with a lower cost basis.
  • The advisory fee is usually above an index ETF's expense ratio, and each provider sets a minimum.
  • The portfolio drifts from the index. This tracking error grows with customization.
  • It does nothing in an IRA or 401(k).

Sources and further reading

  1. IRS — Topic No. 409, Capital gains and losses ($3,000 limit)
  2. IRS — Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses (wash sales)
  3. SEC press release 2023-80 — Betterment tax-loss harvesting disclosures (April 18, 2023)