Skip to content
Menu

Alpha Buying: Ares Is Buying What Wall Street Is Afraid Of

Tim Melvin 23 hours ago

Opinion

Most of you know Ares through a dividend check. You own Ares Capital (ARCC), collect the income, and occasionally flinch when somebody on television announces that private credit is about to destroy civilization.Fewer

Most of you know Ares through a dividend check. You own Ares Capital (ARCC), collect the income, and occasionally flinch when somebody on television announces that private credit is about to destroy civilization.

Fewer of you know the story of Ares Management (ARES), the organization behind that lending machine.

I think the story matters because it explains why its recent buying has me sitting straight up in my chair.

Ares has been adding to selected business development companies while much of Wall Street treats private credit like a stray dog at a picnic. In my opinion, this is the best credit shop in the country. These people spend their working lives evaluating borrowers, negotiating financing agreements, and calculating what they can recover when things go wrong. When they start buying other lenders, I want to know what they see. They have considerably more experience with corporate credit than the internet experts who discovered the subject sometime last Thursday.

How Ares Built Its Credit Investing Franchise

The story starts long before private credit became fashionable. Antony “Tony” Ressler worked in the high-yield bond department at Drexel Burnham Lambert, where he ran the new issue and syndicate desk. John Kissick joined Drexel in 1975 and eventually headed corporate finance. Both helped found Apollo in 1990, overseeing capital markets activities involving high-yield bonds, leveraged loans, and other fixed-income investments.

That work provided a graduate education in how businesses finance themselves and what happens when the cash coming through the door fails to match the projections. The second lesson interests me far more than any breathless presentation about an enormous addressable market. A lender has to know who gets paid first, what collateral protects the money, and how much trouble a business can withstand before its obligations become unmanageable.

Ressler and Kissick launched Ares in 1997 to pursue opportunities in credit. The firm’s famous group of five cofounders came together over several years. Bennett Rosenthal arrived in 1998, David Kaplan in 2003, and Michael Arougheti in 2004. Ares recognizes all five as cofounders, even though they did not all show up on opening day. Think of it as a lineup built one signing at a time, with each player bringing something that helped the firm grow beyond its original business.

Ressler was the builder. He connected the financing markets with business ownership and turned that into an institution capable of attracting capital and repeatedly finding opportunities. Anybody can hit one home run. Building a franchise that keeps producing them is a different job, and Ressler did it. Kissick supplied institutional memory stretching across several generations of credit markets before retiring in 2019 and leaving the board in February 2020.

Rosenthal came from Merrill Lynch, where he was a managing director in global leveraged finance. He became a central figure in Ares private equity and served for years as chairman and later cochairman of Ares Capital. Today, he chairs the Ares Private Equity Group and holds the title of chairman emeritus at ARCC.

Kaplan brought hands-on experience owning and overseeing real businesses. He worked at Apollo from 1991 through 2000 and then at Shelter Capital Partners before joining Ares. His board experience includes Floor & Decor, Maidenform, Smart & Final, and Allied Waste. Those are companies with employees, customers, and operating headaches that last long after the financing closes. That experience teaches you the difference between a pretty financial structure and a good underlying company.

Arougheti came from Royal Bank of Canada, where he was a managing partner in the principal finance group at RBC Capital Partners, following earlier positions at Indosuez Capital and Kidder, Peabody. His arrival in 2004 helped shape the direct lending business that income investors know today. That same year, Ares Capital went public, giving individual investors a way to participate in corporate financing through a publicly traded business development company.

The structure gave Ares a lasting foundation. An ARCC shareholder who wants out sells to another investor, while the company continues holding its loans. When investments take years to mature, that is a very useful arrangement. Ares Capital subsequently acquired Allied Capital in April 2010 and American Capital in January 2017, demonstrating how access to capital can create opportunities following periods of financial upheaval.

The rest of the organization continued expanding. Its credit business reached Europe in 2007, and the 2013 acquisition of AREA Property Partners added real estate. Ares Management itself began trading on the New York Stock Exchange in May 2014. Investors could then choose between ARCC, the lender, and ARES, the asset manager collecting management fees and performance compensation across the broader organization. Arougheti became CEO in January 2018, with Ressler moving to executive chairman.

That history matters because it tells us who is making the investment decisions. These are people who have spent decades examining credit markets, valuing businesses, negotiating financing arrangements, and navigating difficult economic environments. When a firm with that background starts increasing its exposure to other publicly traded lenders, I want to investigate.

What Ares Has Been Buying

The latest holdings disclosures make the story particularly interesting. Form 13F reports provide a delayed snapshot of certain securities held at the end of a quarter. They do not reveal an investment manager’s entire portfolio, explain every position, or establish exactly when each transaction occurred. But comparing filings can show where an experienced investment organization has increased its exposure.

Ares reported larger positions in Barings BDC (BBDC), Blue Owl Technology Finance (OTF), and Crescent Capital BDC (CCAP), finishing the quarter with approximately $79.2 million invested across the three. People who know corporate lending better than almost anyone are finding opportunities in publicly traded lenders at a time when investors have become deeply concerned about private credit.

That is a terrific place to start digging, but it is not the finish line. Credit quality, dividend coverage, and valuation still need a hard look.

Barings BDC (BBDC): A 12.1% Yield at a Discount to NAV

Barings BDC finances middle-market businesses through a portfolio of corporate debt, drawing on the experience and resources of its external investment manager. Ares added 518,500 shares, increasing its position by approximately 12.5%. That brought its reported holdings to 4,682,827 shares, worth roughly $40.4 million.

The regular quarterly dividend is $0.26 per share, or $1.04 annually. At the November 13 share price of $8.59, that represents a yield of approximately 12.1%. September net asset value was $10.92 per share, putting the shares at roughly a 21% discount to reported NAV.

A double-digit income stream purchased below reported net asset value deserves attention, provided the loans supporting those valuations are sound. The important qualification is dividend coverage. Third-quarter net investment income was $0.26 per share, exactly matching the regular quarterly dividend. That leaves no cushion at all, and borrower performance, financing costs, and future earnings will determine whether the payout remains sustainable.

Ares increasing its position makes Barings considerably more interesting. But the financial statements still get the final vote.

Blue Owl Technology Finance (NYSE:OTF): A 14.7% Yield With Questions to Answer

Blue Owl Technology Finance is the specialist of the group, lending to technology businesses, particularly software companies. Ares added 509,637 shares, increasing its position by approximately 25.9%. The reported holding reached 2,475,982 shares, worth roughly $24.3 million.

Software lending can be a wonderful business when borrowers have recurring revenue, established customers, and products deeply integrated into their customers’ daily operations. But a lender must judge how long those advantages will last as competition, technology, and customer budgets change. A famous product name or a gaudy subscription growth rate does not repay a loan.

Blue Owl’s regular quarterly dividend is $0.35 per share, or $1.40 annually. At the November 13 closing price of $9.52, that represents a regular dividend yield of approximately 14.7%, excluding the listing-related special dividends that have now finished.

The challenge is that third-quarter adjusted net investment income was $0.29 per share, below the regular quarterly payout. That is a meaningful gap. We need to determine whether future investment deployment, financing expenses, and portfolio performance can improve earnings enough to support the dividend. The yield is huge because the market has huge concerns.

Ares’s increased position tells us an experienced credit investor sees something worth owning. Our job is to examine the portfolio and determine whether the potential reward justifies the risks.

Crescent Capital BDC (NASDAQ:CCAP): A 43% Discount to Reported NAV

Crescent Capital BDC provides another particularly interesting combination of income and valuation. Ares purchased an additional 492,193 shares, increasing its position by approximately 45.2%. Its reported holding reached 1,580,376 shares, worth roughly $14.5 million.

Crescent lends primarily to middle-market companies through a portfolio concentrated in first-lien and unitranche first-lien loans. At the end of September, it held investments in 190 companies.

The regular quarterly dividend is $0.34 per share, or $1.36 annually. At the November 13 closing price of $10.13, that represents a regular yield of approximately 13.4%, excluding the final previously declared $0.03 special dividend. Third-quarter net investment income was $0.37 per share, providing coverage of the regular payout.

The valuation is even more striking. September net asset value was $17.72 per share, putting the stock at approximately a 43% discount to reported NAV. That is enormous. Of course, a large discount does not automatically mean a stock is cheap. Crescent’s NAV declined from $19.28 a year earlier, so the important question is how much additional deterioration the current share price already assumes.

There are also capital allocation developments worth watching. Crescent authorized a $50 million share repurchase program, while Sun Life plans to purchase up to $25 million of additional shares. Buying stock far below net asset value can benefit remaining shareholders, provided the underlying asset values hold.

Between the substantial discount, dividend coverage, potential repurchases, and Ares’s increased position, Crescent gives us several reasons to investigate further. The loans themselves will determine whether the apparent bargain is real.

MSC Income Fund (NYSE:MSIF): Another BDC Attracting Ares Capital

Ares’s increased exposure to publicly traded lenders extends beyond Barings, Blue Owl Technology Finance, and Crescent Capital. The firm also increased its position in MSC Income Fund (MSIF) by approximately 29.9%, adding 378,794 shares. Its reported holding was worth approximately $19.4 million.

That increase is worth noting because it broadens the pattern of buying across the business development company sector. Rather than concentrating all its additional exposure in a single lender, Ares reported increased positions in several companies operating in the same general credit market.

The position also gives us another opportunity to investigate how experienced investors are evaluating publicly traded lenders during a period of skepticism toward private credit. I would want to examine MSC Income Fund’s underlying portfolio, dividend coverage, financing costs, and valuation before drawing conclusions about its attractiveness.

The filing tells us that Ares increased its exposure, but it does not establish that the investment is inexpensive or that its income stream is secure. Those questions require the same financial discipline we apply to the other lenders.

Put these positions together, and we have a useful rebuttal to the notion that experienced credit investors are universally running for the exits. That does not mean every publicly traded lender is attractive. It means some investors with considerable credit experience are finding opportunities worth pursuing.

FTAI Infrastructure (NASDAQ:FIP): Buying More Shares as the Price Falls

Ares also increased its position in FTAI Infrastructure (FIP) by approximately 48.4%, purchasing another 579,705 shares. That brought the reported holding to 1,777,259 shares, worth roughly $4.9 million.

There is an important lesson in the filing. The reported market value of the position declined from the previous quarter even though Ares purchased more shares. Falling share prices more than offset the increase in shares owned. Always check the share count, not just the reported market value. Otherwise, you can completely misunderstand what an investment manager has been doing.

FTAI Infrastructure owns railroads, terminals, and power assets, including Transtar, Jefferson Terminal in Beaumont, Texas, Repauno on the Delaware River, and Long Ridge on the Ohio River. Those are large, tangible assets with important roles in transportation, logistics, and energy infrastructure.

But owning valuable assets does not automatically make the common stock attractive. Common shareholders receive what remains after operating expenses, debt service, and capital spending. Ares also holds a preferred financing position in FIP, with protections and economics that differ from those of the common shares discussed here.

That distinction matters. The investment case for a preferred security is not necessarily the same as the investment case for common equity. I want to understand the company’s debt obligations, capital requirements, and the cash flow available to shareholders before deciding whether the common shares offer an attractive opportunity.

Ares’s increased common-stock position gives us a reason to investigate, but the financial structure will determine whether that opportunity is worthwhile.

Hornbeck Offshore Services (OTC:HOS): A $210.9 Million Position

Then there is the big swing. Ares disclosed 27,425,763 shares of Hornbeck Offshore Services (HOS), worth approximately $210.9 million. That represented roughly 10.7% of the reported 13F portfolio, making Hornbeck the second-largest disclosed position.

Hornbeck provides offshore marine transportation, subsea services, and well intervention for energy producers, offshore contractors, and government customers. Its specialized vessels can become extremely valuable when demand strengthens and replacement vessels are expensive and slow to build.

That creates an interesting asset-based investment opportunity. A capable offshore fleet may have considerable earning power when customers need equipment that cannot be replaced quickly. But offshore services remain cyclical. Demand changes with energy investment, and the maintenance bills keep arriving even when a vessel sits idle.

Fleet earning power, replacement value, and debt will ultimately determine what shareholders receive. Ares’s large position makes Hornbeck worth examining, but the size of the holding is not a substitute for understanding the business.

What Ares’s Buying Tells Us About Today’s Credit Market

For Alpha Buying readers, these disclosures provide a loaded list of places to investigate. Ares built its reputation by understanding borrowers, valuing assets, structuring financing arrangements, and maintaining the resources to act when opportunities appeared. Its investment teams have experience across high-yield bonds, leveraged loans, direct lending, private equity, real estate, and specialized assets.

That experience matters when markets become uncomfortable. A lender trading at a double-digit dividend yield may represent an attractive income opportunity, or it may be signaling that the market expects weaker earnings and future dividend reductions. A large discount to net asset value may represent an opportunity to purchase assets cheaply, or it may indicate that investors expect those reported values to decline. We have to determine which explanation fits the facts.

Barings offers a substantial yield and a discount to NAV, but its latest net investment income only matched the dividend. Blue Owl Technology Finance offers an even higher yield, although its latest adjusted investment income fell short of the regular payout. Crescent combines a particularly large discount to reported NAV with current dividend coverage, although declining asset values deserve scrutiny.

MSC Income Fund adds another publicly traded lender to the list, while FTAI Infrastructure and Hornbeck Offshore Services demonstrate that Ares is also maintaining significant exposure to specialized physical assets. These are not identical investment opportunities. Their risks, capital structures, and sources of earnings differ considerably.

But they share an important characteristic: experienced investors are willing to commit capital to businesses and assets that much of the market currently views with skepticism.

That is exactly where I want to look for potential bargains.

Ares has spent decades learning how to evaluate businesses when credit conditions become difficult. Its teams understand that lending profits depend not merely on the interest rate charged but on whether borrowers can repay and what can be recovered when they cannot. The latest holdings disclosures suggest those teams continue to find opportunities in selected lenders and specialized infrastructure businesses.

I am not interested in blindly copying every position. Ares may have different financing arrangements, investment horizons, and portfolio objectives than we do. I am interested in using its activity to identify businesses that deserve a closer look.

We can examine the loans, test the dividends, compare market prices with asset values, and determine whether the potential returns compensate us for the risks.

When the best scouting department in the league starts signing players the crowd is booing, I would like to know why. Then I would like to check the numbers myself.

Read at benzinga.com